Captive is a captivating song that tells the story of Garfield discovering Jon's former roommate, Lyman, bound in the basement. The track features a brief segment where Garfield and Lyman sing together for just over a minute. However, the mood shifts dramatically when Garfield hears Jon's footsteps approaching. Jon enters with a sinister laugh, making a subtle gesture that sends chills down Garfield's spine. As Jon's demeanor becomes increasingly erratic, his small pupils hint at a disturbing madness. He confronts Garfield with a dish of lasagna, Garfield's favorite meal, which adds a chilling twist to the scene. The horrifying truth dawns on Garfield: Lyman is chained up, and skeletal remains litter the floor, revealing Jon as a serial killer who uses his victims' flesh to create lasagna. Now trapped, Garfield faces Jon, who is intent on forcing him to eat. Will Garfield be able to escape this terrifying fate, or will he uncover Jon's dark secrets before more innocent lives are lost, putting an end to this nightmare once and for all?